Local Mortgage Information for Your Area
Comparing Second Mortgages and Refinancing for Home Improvements
Both
refinancing (in particular,
cash-out refinancing) and
second mortgages (either through a
home equity loan or a
home equity line of credit) let homeowners access
home equity.
Deciding between the two depends on the same criteria used to decide between cash-out refinancing or second mortgages for any eventual purpose. They include:
- flexibility
- how much money is needed
- when the money is needed
- closing costs and annual fees
- budgeting monthly payments
- financial discipline
- length of loan period
- interest rates
With cash-out financing, the flexibility is the lowest. Not only does the money come in a lump sum-like with a home equity loan-it is also less likely to be a selectable amount.
Additionally, closing costs and fees will likely be higher than that for a second mortgage. However, the potential benefits of the new mortgage (lower monthly payments and/or reduced interest) can certainly outweigh this disadvantage.
But, perhaps the most importance difference-and whether it is an advantage or disadvantage-has to do with the nature of refinancing and second mortgages. Second mortgages, by definition, are an additional loan (or put another way: more
debt).
The bottom line is that only the borrower-with accurate information that is carefully analyzed-can determine the ultimate advantages between a second mortgage and cash-out refinancing.
Next: Do you want to experiment with a home equity calculator or a refinance calculator, or would you like to be matched with up to five home equity and second mortgage lenders or matched with up to five mortgage refinance lenders?